What Does a Business Really Gain When It Offers Its Customers a Loyalty Program?
Author: The CompassBG team
Published:
Reading time: 7 minutes
When a business offers a loyalty program, it gains additional sales at a low cost, more frequent purchases, longer attention from the customer and a direct relationship with them that does not depend on advertising platforms. In our practice at CompassBG, the cost of a well-managed program is between 10 and 20% of the revenue it brings in.
If you sell to end customers, you should seriously consider introducing a loyalty program. That is the advice our video on the topic opens with, and it is how we open this article too.
Petrol stations, supermarket chains, clothing stores. Almost every large retailer has a customer card with points. Many people assume the only reason is collecting data. From our experience at CompassBG, where for more than 11 years and in more than 400 projects we have been building online stores, mobile apps and marketing systems, that is at most half of the answer.
A loyalty program changes the relationship between the customer and the brand. From one-sided and simple, it becomes two-way and based on partnership: the customer gives the brand something, and the brand gives something back in return.
▶ Prefer to watch? On YouTube (in Bulgarian) we use real numbers to explain how points and tiers increase sales. Watch the video on loyalty programs.
Contents
- What does a business gain from a loyalty program?
- Why is a loyalty program not just a tool for collecting data?
- How do points increase the value of the next purchase?
- What does a 100 euro bonus really cost the business?
- What does the business gain when the customer chooses a free product?
- How do loyalty program tiers increase purchases?
- Why is more frequent interaction with the brand a gain for the business?
- What is a direct relationship with the customer worth?
- How much does a loyalty program cost compared to the revenue it brings in?
- When does a loyalty program not pay off, and where should you start?
1. What does a business gain from a loyalty program?
The business gains additional sales at a low cost, more frequent purchases, more attention from the customer and a direct channel of communication with them. Points and bonuses are the price it pays for these benefits.
Every loyalty program we build has two main goals. The first is to increase revenue. The second is higher customer satisfaction and retention, so that the customer interacts with the brand more often and for longer. The second goal is a gain in itself, because a retained customer buys again without new advertising spend.
Research by Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company, cited in Harvard Business Review, shows that a 5% increase in customer retention can increase profits by between 25% and 95%. According to the same source, acquiring a new customer costs 5 to 25 times more than retaining an existing one.
▶ In the video: Why introduce a loyalty program (00:00)
2. Why is a loyalty program not just a tool for collecting data?
Because its main value lies in the relationship it creates. Data is a useful side effect, while the profit comes from a customer who has a reason to come back.
A customer who collects points already has something "with you". When they choose where to shop next time, they do not compare prices alone. They also calculate what they lose if they go to a competitor. In our view, this is the difference between a random buyer and a partner who comes back of their own accord.
3. How do points increase the value of the next purchase?
The customer sees the collected points as a gift, so they easily spend more than they planned. This psychology works in the business's favour.
An example from our video:
For every 1 euro spent, the customer gets 1 point. After 1000 euros of purchases, they have 1000 points, which equal a 100 euro bonus. On their next order they use the bonus and, because they see it as a gift, they go over the amount they intended to spend.
▶ In the video: How the program increases sales and revenue (01:13)
4. What does a 100 euro bonus really cost the business?
With a 40% margin, a 100 euro bonus costs the business about 60 euros. The discount is covered with goods, not with cash.
| Metric | Value in the example |
|---|---|
| Amount spent by the customer | 1000 € |
| Points collected | 1000 points |
| Bonus value for the customer | 100 € |
| Real cost to the business at a 40% margin | 60 € |
| Expected revenue from the next purchases | between 1500 and 2000 € |
If we asked you whether you would pay 60 euros up front for an ad that brings in between 1500 and 2000 euros of revenue, the answer would almost certainly be "yes". A loyalty program follows the same logic, but the cost comes after the sale, not before it.
5. What does the business gain when the customer chooses a free product?
It gains an opportunity for an additional sale. The customer arrives ready to shop, and the free product is the reason they came, not the end goal.
Whether they walk into the physical store, visit the online store or call by phone, the customer has already chosen a product they like and is ready to be your customer. That is why we advise our clients to offer something that complements the gift at exactly this moment. In both cases, a discount or a free product, revenue from the customer grows at minimal cost. We describe similar logic in the article on a profitable Black Friday campaign, where a gift with purchase replaces a price cut.
6. How do loyalty program tiers increase purchases?
Tiers give the customer a goal, and people speed up their purchases as they get closer to the goal. Each next tier brings more points, a higher point value or new bonuses.
First tier
At 1000 euros spent.
Second tier
Up to 10 000 euros spent.
Third tier
Up to 20 000 euros spent.
The customer is inclined to spend a little more to reach the next tier.
The effect is also confirmed by research. Researchers from Columbia Business School found that participants in a "buy 10 coffees, get 1 free" program buy more often the closer they get to the reward.
▶ In the video: Program tiers and customer loyalty (03:08)
7. Why is more frequent interaction with the brand a gain for the business?
Every time the customer checks their points and tier, they think about your brand, and you do not pay for that attention.
The customer checks which tier they are on, how many points they have, how many they will get from the next order and what they can use them for. On top of that come the notifications about a new tier and new points. All of these increase satisfaction and the moments of contact with the company, the brand and the product. The most convenient channel for such notifications is often a mobile app, which is why we also recommend our article on push notifications in online commerce.
8. What is a direct relationship with the customer worth?
A direct relationship is the most valuable thing the program provides. It lets the business communicate with its customers without depending on advertising platforms and react to problems in time.
In 2026, few brands can boast of such a relationship. In one of our meetings, the owner of a business with a high-quality product told us that the share of sales to customers who had bought before was zero. The product lasts four to five years, and every sale depends on a new customer and new advertising spend. A loyalty program reverses exactly this model.
We write more about it in the article which business survives in the long term, and the practical steps after the purchase are in our piece on customer retention.
▶ In the video: The direct relationship with customers (05:12)
9. How much does a loyalty program cost compared to the revenue it brings in?
In the programs we at CompassBG run and track, the cost is between 10 and 20% of the revenue the program brings in. That is comparable to a well-performing advertising campaign.
If we asked you for 1000 euros for an advertising campaign that will bring you 10 000 euros, would you pay it? If you hired an employee for 1000 euros and they brought you 10 000 euros, would you hire them? A loyalty program puts you in front of the same decision.
Our observations are confirmed by external data as well. A 2020 McKinsey survey shows that members of free loyalty programs are 30% more likely to spend more on the brand, and members of paid programs 60% more likely.
Doing the math before the decision is a must. We recently calculated a possible TV ad for a client: to break even, the business would have had to sell about two and a half times more than in its strongest month, and we decided not to go ahead. Compare the program's cost with the return on your online advertising and see how to plan your marketing budget.
▶ In the video: Cost versus revenue: data from our practice (04:34)
10. When does a loyalty program not pay off, and where should you start?
The program does not pay off when it is the same for everyone and is not adjusted to the margin and the behaviour of customers. Start with the math: margin, average order and purchase frequency.
A McKinsey study of 55 publicly traded companies shows that companies that spend more on loyalty do not necessarily grow faster than the rest. In our view, the conclusion is not that programs do not work, but that mass discounts without a strategy destroy value. Our position is clear: the program has to adapt constantly to the needs and feedback of customers.
Point value
Determine what one point costs at your real margin.
Tiers
Set thresholds that are achievable but require a few more purchases.
Notifications
Choose a channel, such as email, Viber or push notifications in an app.
Cost and revenue
Track the ratio and adjust the rules regularly.
Technically, the program can be built into an online store or a mobile app as part of a complete digital sales system. If you would like us to calculate a program for your business, get in touch and the CompassBG team will prepare the numbers together with you.
Key takeaways
- A loyalty program turns a one-off purchase into a two-way partnership between the customer and the brand.
- A 100 euro bonus at a 40% margin costs about 60 euros and can bring in between 1500 and 2000 euros of revenue.
- Tiers and notifications increase purchase frequency and contact with the brand without advertising spend.
- In our practice, the cost is between 10 and 20% of the revenue the program brings in.
- The biggest gain is the direct relationship with the customer, which does not depend on advertising platforms.
▶ Watch the full episode on YouTube (in Bulgarian). We use real numbers to show why a loyalty program is one of the cheapest ways to increase sales and build a direct relationship with your customers. Watch the video now.
Sources
- CompassBG: What does a business really gain when it offers a loyalty program? (YouTube, in Bulgarian)
- Harvard Business Review: The Value of Keeping the Right Customers
- Columbia Business School: The Goal-Gradient Hypothesis Resurrected (Kivetz, Urminsky, Zheng, 2006)
- McKinsey & Company: Coping with the big switch: How paid loyalty programs can help bring consumers back to your brand
- McKinsey & Company: Making loyalty pay: Six lessons from the innovators
